Angie and Candice have never been in the bottom since the semis. In fact both women have been in the top, twice, in recent week. So could the shocker this year come from an elimination of Angie or Candice?

And then there is Kree and Amber. Traditional Idol results send home contestants who keep on landing in the bottom. Both these women have been in the bottom at least once in the last two telecasts. So could Kree and Amber be most in jeopardy of elimination this week?

Tonight, Amber was first up with “The Power of Love” by Celine Dion. And while viewers were mixed about the performance, the judges loved it. Three of four judges stood up. Keith said the song choice was perfect. Nicki said that Amber is the “most current contestant” in the show. Randy said that Amber had improved the most. Mariah said she was impressed.

Candice chose “Find Your Love” by Drake. Nicki had mixed feels about the performance, and wondered if Candice should have focused more on the melody. Randy, however, thought the vocals were exceptional. Mariah agreed, saying that Candice had command of the song. Keith disagreed with Nicki but agreed to Mariah.

Next up with Kree with “It Hurt So Bad”. Randy didn’t give Kree good reviews. He told news that she was “disconnected”. Mariah disagreed and said the performance showed Kree’s versatility. Keith loved the song selection, and the vocals. But Keith thought, once again, that Kree lacked emotion. Nicki too was bothered with the performance and said it was not top 4 worthy.

Angie Miller chose “Who You Are” by Jessie J. And in the end, all the judges expect Mariah gave it a standing ovation. Keith said that Angie was tight at the beginning but eventually got into the song. Nicki thought it was spotless. Randy said it was a perfect “10″ and the best performance of the night.

For now, if the judges’ remarks are any indication, Kree is dominating elimination predictions for Idol 3 results tomorrow night.

Prior to American Idol 2013 results tonight, two women seemed in jeopardy. In recent weeks, Amber Holcomb and Janelle Arthur have found themselves in the bottom. One week ago, it was Amber in the bottom with Lazaro; but she survived. Two weeks ago, it was Janelle in the bottom with Burnell; and she survived as well.

Moreover, prior to tonight’s telecast, the other three women have been dominating votes. Kree has been in the top two now three times this season. Candice and Angie have achieve the same distinction as well, twice.

But did Amber rebound this week? Amber previously surprised news the week of Lazaro’s elimination. That night she ended in the bottom, even though she impressed the judges. Holcomb chose Say a Little Prayer. Keith reminded her you can “never over sing”. Nicki was blown away, commenting “I am bowing down for you”. Randy also assured Amber that she was safe as well. But ultimately, she ended in the bottom of voting that week

And how about Janelle? The week that Burnell was eliminated, she got mixed reviews as well. Only some of the judges liked Janelle Arthur with “You May Be Right.” Mariah remarked that she “loved the key, enjoyed your vibrato”.

Keith Urban told news that he loved Candice Glover’s version of the song. He also admitted forgetting how good a song it was. Nicki Minaj told Keith that the song was always a great track. She told Candice that she loved her performance and was happy that she made the Top 5. Randy agreed that the performance was well done and Mariah said that she enjoyed Candice’s version of the song.

So with Arthur not getting Paula’s song, Janelle selected When You Call My Name (Vince Gill). Janelle accompanied the song with her guitar. Nicki told news that she prefers Janelle singing with guitar. But Nicki was bothered by the end of the performance. Randy disagreed and told news that the entire performance was strong and one of Janelle’s best ever. Mariah agreed with Randy.

But Keith Urban disagreed with the rest of the panel. He said that he didn’t like the performance, he said the notes were off, and he didn’t like her on guitar. Mariah eventually interrupted Keith and expressed her disapproval of his remarks.

Who could end up in the bottom three tomorrow? Janelle and Amber have to be careful. Last week the top was Amber Holcomb and Lazaro Arbos. A week before that it was Janelle Arthur and Burnell Taylor.
Of the remaining Top 5 singers, only Janelle and Amber have ever been in the bottom. Amber has been there twice, Janelle once.

The competition now finally gets interesting with five strong signers left in the competition and no clear frontrunner. Janelle Arthur has ended in the bottom two only once back on April 4. Candice Glover has never visited the bottom, nor has Kree Harrison or Angie Miller. But Amber Holcomb has visited the bottom twice since March. Based upon Idol historical track-record, Amber could be back in jeopardy next week if she doesn’t improve dramatically.

But who are the leaders? Candice has been in the top 3 twice, while Angie and Kree have done it twice. Last night, the top two were Candice and Kree, and the bottom two were Lazaro and Amber.

More recently, Lazaro Arbos drew mired reviews for his duet with Angie Miller on Crazy Little Thing Called Love. Seven day ago, Randy told news that he liked Angie but didn’t enjoy Arbos. But Mariah came to Arbos’ defense, saying that that it is hard for any male to sing Freddie Mercury’s notes. Keith told news that the “vibe was wrong”.

As one viewer commented last week, “[people] want Lazaro off of the show because he doesn’t deserve to be there by doing a mediocre job week after week. Yet he continues to get votes and while no one is expecting him to apologize, I do think that everyone is expecting him to go home this week.”

Meantime, there has been a real disagreement about who might be in the final Top 3 this season. As one viewer commented “I am glad Amber Holcomb stayed, she is undeniably the best singer in this competition” while another claims “by far Jenelle is the best singer and plays to the audience”.