LOS ANGELES (LALATE) – Spencer Pratt’s claims about a Heidi Montag tape are inconsistent with Montag’s only claims about her health earlier this year. Spencer Pratt has told news that at least one tape has been recorded between him and Heidi Montag after her recent plastic surgeries procedure. But Pratt’s claim is inconsistent with Montag’s own claim about her condition at the time.

Pratt claims Montag had the ability to record a tape post surgery. But Montag told news at the time that she didn’t even have the ability to jog let alone hug people.

In April 2010, Heidi Montag told news at the time that she couldn’t even hug Pratt. “I’m very weird about hugging people now – [my body] is very fragile.” Montag added that she couldn’t jog either. By May 2010, Pratt and Montag had split.

If such a tape was recorded by Pratt and Montag in the month of April or earlier, it would seemingly contradict Montag’s own statements about her health at the time.  This would not be the first time that news questioned Montag’s comments post surgery. In April, while claiming she couldn’t hug people, Montag also claimed she had her back scooped out.  When Ryan Seacrest asked her what that procedure involved, Montag said “I actually didn’t know.” She went on to say she thought she was the first person to ever have a “back scooped” procedure. “I might be the first one to try it. It carves out your back a little bit” she then told US Magazine. She added she “had my waist cinched in on both sides.”

Pratt has yet to confirm if his alleged tapes features Montag before, with her whole back, and after with her back allegedly “scooped”.

In May, the relationship between Montag and Pratt deteriorated. Montag confirmed a professional split before an end in their marriage. “We are no longer Speidi but Spencer and Heidi”. “The time for change is now. Never mix business and pleasure. We are no longer Speidi but Spencer and Heidi.”  Last night, Montag tweeted she was simply “crying”. It’s a dramatic change from earlier this summer when she tweeted “Finally, the sun is out… … Swimming in my pool I love summer this is the first summer of my new life.”